Post by oldpop2000 on Feb 17, 2014 22:07:28 GMT -5
Alex and Phoenix:
You gents need to document your actions in detail for the NWS Team because in my opinion, the results for at least Bismarck and Hood are not realistic. In real life, against a battleship that could do no more than five knots in a circle, Rodney and KGV never got anything near a kill shot. Results from dives on the wreck, show that she might have been sunk by her charges, not the torpedoes from British cruisers or British 15 inch and 16 inch guns. Just my opinion. My suggestion is to continue to keep playing, gathering the results and ensure that all parameters that are changed are documented for the team.
Again, my suggestion. The team may have other ideas. Here is a good website to refer to, to help make changes to the game. For discussions of the real event, remember the thread on the military history forum for that expressed purpose.
I think you may have missed Randomizers point - the internal game code in SAI is hardwired for the WW1 era, and likely will not give proper results for most WW2 battles with only the minor external data changes that can be made by players. These results do not represent a bug, since the game by definition is not designed nor intended to handle the WW2 era.
Now feedback is fine, but I honestly do not see how feedback on WW2-era SAI scenarios will help with a game designed for a significantly different period.